The Quebec Experiment #3: Eat Stop Eat

November 17th, 2010 by M

The subject of this new experiment is to test the Eat Stop Eat (ESE) diet created by Brad Pilon.

From my understanding, ESE is quit simple. All I have to do are mini fasts (24 hrs each), once or twice per week and make sure I also do resistance training (to preserve lean mass). For training, Brad suggests 2-3 times per week.

My goals for this experiment are:

  1. How ESE compares with a “classic” constant calorie deficit diet (my Quebec experiment #2)?
  2. Will I preserve all my hard-earned muscle, as Brad says in the book?
  3. And a more subjective goal, can I convert the diet into a lifestyle?

I’m really curious about goal #2. Last time I did a fast, it was a disaster: almost half of my loss was lean mass! I must tell that the fast was a week long (which is crazy, I know).

The duration of this experiment is again 3 month. And yes, it will conflict with Christmas vacations… My rational for doing this anyway is there are conflicts all the time. I cannot wait for the perfect time to start doing things.

My current schedule looks like this:

  • Monday and Thursday: Fast.
  • Tuesday and Friday: strength training.
  • Wednesday: cardio.

I plan to take my BKI (body weight, fat%, fat and lean mass) on Fridays and will start this Friday, Nov. 19.

Until then, Lift Consciously sig_logo

The Quebec Experiment #2 – Conclusions

October 19th, 2010 by M

Hey! I’ve been away long enough now… Let’s get going!

The goal of this experiment#2 was for me to drop my fat % down to 15. By looking to my latest BKI, I think we can call it a draw…

According to my “BIA-T” at 16.9%, it’s a near miss.  But if I compute the average for the 3 methods, I’m pretty close to my goal (15.3%)!

Here’s a graph that shows how my BKI evolved over the 3 month period:

And a data grid of the exact numbers:

Start Finish Diff
BW 158.8 144.6 -14.2
LM 124 120.16 -3.84
FM 34.8 24.44 -10.36

(All weights in lbs.)

What are my take home lessons? Difficult to say, in fact…

I did not make this experiment in a controlled environment. I was mixing it with the “usual me”. I’m the kind of guy who have a tendency to go overboard without even thinking about it. I was, I think (even if I took no record about my intakes), on a constant calorie deficit.

So, after the fact, it’s no surprise I lost 10.36 lbs of fat (FM). The other fact is I lost 3.84 lbs (the target was zero lbs!) of muscle (LM). That should not be a surprise either.

My take home lesson would be this. It wasn’t that difficult to lose weight after I made the choice (or was able?) to be in a constant calorie deficit. The difficult part was the dark side of it: lean mass loss. But again, this was my choice.

My priority was to drop fat % and this is what I got…

On a final note, I suggest you read this post by Rusty Moore about “How to Gain Muscle and Lose Fat at the Same Time”.

Until next post, Lift Consciously sig_logo

M’s Body Key Indicator #18

May 31st, 2010 by M

Here’s my 18th post of a series about my Body Key Indicators or BKI.

My BKI for Thursday May 20, 2010 are…

Method Body Weight Fat % Fat Mass Lean Mass
BIA-T 144.6 (-1.6) lbs 16.9 (-0.8) 24.44 (-1.44) 120.16 (-0.16)
BIA-W 144.7 (-1.7) lbs 14.1 (-0.6) 20.4 (-1.2) 124.3 (-0.5)
J/P3 Using BIA-T 14.85 (-0.6) 21.47 (-1.11) 123.13 (+0.51)
Legend:

  • BIA-T = Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis with a body scale from Taylor brand.
  • BIA-W = BIA using a body scale from Withings brand.
  • J/P3 = Jackson/Pollock 3 sites caliper method.

These results are interesting. According to the BIA-T method, I managed to lose almost 1.5 lbs of fat (1.44). Even more interesting is that I almost preserved my lean mass in the process (a loss of 0.16 lb).

Until next post, Lift Consciously sig_logo